Using Charge Determination Design of Experiments to Develop A Refrigerant Charge Health Status Model for Heat Pump Systems



Published Oct 26, 2023
Hong Wong Hadyan Ramadhan Alaeddin Bani Milhim Hossein Sadjadi


Refrigerant based heat pump systems are becoming an integral system in electric vehicle architectures due to their high efficiencies in providing heating and cooling to people and components within the car.  An important component in heat pump systems that determines optimal efficiency is the amount of refrigerant.  As such, the capability to model refrigerant charge helps quantify the health status of the heat pump system, whereby the lack or over abundance of refrigerant in a heat pump refrigerant system leads to various other component failures, e.g., liquid slugging, compressor overheating, material fatigue in heat exchanger, and degraded/stuck expansion valves.  In designing a heat pump system, engineers need to perform a set of design of experiments to determine an optimal refrigerant charge based on a set of performance metrics in the presence of certain noise factors.  This optimal refrigerant charge provides conditions where the heat pump system operates efficiently in both heating and cooling, in addition to facilitating operational conditions that will not lead to secondary component degradation or damage.  The search for optimal refrigerant charge is classified as refrigerant charge determination, whereby engineers incrementally increase the refrigerant in the heat pump system in operation of heating/cooling and collect data about performance metrics.  Some of the key performance metrics used to determine efficiency of a heat pump system include i) compressor inlet superheat temperature, ii) condenser outlet subcool temperature, iii) compressor high side pressure, iv) compressor low side pressure, v) condenser outlet pressure, and vi) condenser quality estimate.  Furthermore, this process follows design of experiments concepts and is performed for both heating and cooling modes of operation. In this paper, we leverage refrigerant charge determination as a training data source to develop refrigerant charge models, where several performance metrics are health indicators used as model inputs and the amount of refrigerant added to the heat pump system are ground truth refrigerant charges used as model outputs.  In this paper we develop regression models to  estimate the total refrigerant charge, which is used to classify different health states of refrigerant based on levels of performance degradation corresponding to specific refrigerant charge thresholds.  We trained a robust linear regression model using this charge determination data and found that the worst case estimation error was less than 10% with respect to the refrigerant charge grouth truth.

How to Cite

Wong, H., Ramadhan, H., Bani Milhim, A., & Sadjadi, H. (2023). Using Charge Determination Design of Experiments to Develop A Refrigerant Charge Health Status Model for Heat Pump Systems. Annual Conference of the PHM Society, 15(1).
Abstract 43 | PDF Downloads 33



Charge Determination, Heat Pump System, Health Status Model

Antonijevic, D., & Heckt, R. (2004). Heat pump supplemental heating system for motor vehicles. Journal of Automobile Engineering, vol 218 (10), pp. 1111-1115. doi:10.1177/095440700421801005.
Hannan, M.A., Azidin, F.A., Mohamed, A. (2014). Hybrid electric vehicles and their challenges: A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Review, vol 29, pp. 134-150.
Kim, W.H., & Braun, J.E. (2013). Performance evaluation of a virtual refrigerant charge sensor. International Journal of Refrigeration, vol 36, pp. 1130-1141.
Kim, W.H., & Braun, J. E. (2015). Extension of a virtual refrigerant charge sensor. International Journal of Refrigeration, vol 55, pp. 224-235.
Lemmon, E.W., Bell, I.H., Huber, M.L., McLinden, M.O. NIST Standard Reference Database 23: Reference Fluid Thermodynamic and Transport Properties-REFPROP, Version 10.0, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Standard Reference Data Program, Gaithersburg, 2018.
Li, H., & Braun, J.E. (2009). Development, evaluation and demonstration of a virtual refrigerant charge sensor. HVAC & R Research, vol 15(1), pp. 117-136.
Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) International (2018). R134a Refrigerant Charge Determination Test Method. SAE J3023_201809. Ground Vehicle Standard.
Son, J.E., Nam, S., Kang, K., Lee, J. (2018). Refrigerant Charge Estimation for an Air Conditioning System using Artificial Neural Network Modelling. Proceedings of the International Conference on Control, Automation and Systems. October 17-20, GangWon, Korea.
Qi, Z. (2014). Advances on air conditioning and heat pump system in electric vehicles – A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol 38, pp. 754-764.
Xu, Z., Zhimin, D., Zhijie, C., Xiaoqing H. (2019). Hybrid model based refrigerant charge fault estimation for the data centre air conditioning system. International Journal of Refrigeration, vol 106, pp. 392-406.
Poster Presentations

Most read articles by the same author(s)

1 2 > >>